Prevalence of Alcohol and Other Drug Dependence

Studies shed light on the nature of dependence

The following is a Research Update excerpt from the Butler Center for Research. Download the PDF to read the entire Update

Accurately measuring the prevalence of alcohol and drug dependence is a recurring challenge for researchers. An estimation of current and lifetime dependence is essential for making policy decisions in prevention, treatment, and public health.

What is dependence?

Alcohol and other drug dependence is characterized by a cluster of symptoms that significantly impair life functioning. To satisfy the criteria for dependence in the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) one must have three of the seven following symptoms in the same twelve month period: (1) tolerance; (2) withdrawal or avoidance of withdrawal; (3) substance taken more or for a longer duration than intended; (4) continuing desire or unsuccessful attempts to reduce or control substance use; (5) much time spent to procure, use, or recover from using the substance; (6) elimination or reduction of important social, work, or recreational activities in favor of or because of substance use; (7) and continuing to use the substance despite known psychological or physical repercussions.1

Substance abuse is defined as a harmful pattern of behavior resulting in clinically significant distress or impairment within a 12 month period. Examples of substance abuse behaviors include: failure to fulfill personal or occupational roles, repeated use in physically risky situations, substance-related legal problems, and social or interpersonal problems related to substance use.1

The DSM-IV does not consider amount or frequency of drinking or using. Rather it relies on an established behavioral pattern and harmful consequences of alcohol or other drug use to define dependence. Many investigations of alcohol and drug problems in the general population focus on the extent of illicit drug use or heavy drinking. These estimates, while useful to determine use and related problems, do not measure dependence.


National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiological Survey

In 1992, the National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism funded the National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiological Survey (NLAES).2 This well designed study included a nationally representative survey of 42,862 Americans who completed in-person interviews about the frequency and amount of alcohol and drug use in their lifetimes and the past twelve months. Further, the research measured symptoms of substance abuse and dependence using rigorous DSM-IV criteria. The research was limited in its estimate of prevalence because it did not include residents of mental and physical health care institutions, prisons, and the homeless, who have elevated levels of addictive disorders. As a result of this limitation, the research is most likely an underestimate of overall prevalence in the general population.3

Study Results

Results of the NLAES show clear differences in alcohol and drug use and dependence in the general population (see Figure above).3, 4 Alcohol dependence and use was far more common than drug dependence and use. Lifetime alcohol use, defined as consuming twelve drinks or more in any single year, was reported by 66% of respondents, compared with only 15.6% reporting lifetime drug use, defined as having tried a drug for non-medical purposes at least twelve times.5

Using DSM-IV criteria, 13.3% and 2.9% of respondents reported lifetime alcohol or drug dependence respectively; 4.4% and 0.8% met the criteria for past 12 months alcohol or drug dependence respectively. Of people who had ever used alcohol 20.1% met the criteria for alcohol dependence. Similarly, 18.6% of people who had ever used drugs qualified as drug dependent.3, 4

Demographic Comparisons

More men than women, whites than nonwhites, more educated than less educated, and non-married than married were likely to use drugs. Likewise, more men than women, whites than nonwhites, and more educated than less educated were likely to drink alcohol. In contrast to drug use, married people were more likely than non-married people to drink alcohol.3, 4

Among alcohol users, more men than women, more whites than nonwhites, and more non-married than married, were likely to be alcohol dependent. Among drug users, men and women and whites and nonwhites were equally likely to be drug dependent. However, less educated versus more educated and non-married versus married people were more likely to be drug dependent. It is important to note that, despite differences in demographic groups, substance dependence was found in all demographic categories.3, 4

Treatment Populations

Elevated prevalence of substance use disorders is common among both mental and physical health treatment seekers. Conservative estimates of comorbid substance use disorders in schizophrenics patients are as high as 38%.6 Among people with affective disorders, studies have shown comorbidity rates as low as 11% and as high as 75%.6 Among another group of psychiatric patients, older adults, one study found the prevalence of substance use disorders at one in five patients.7 Alcohol abuse and dependence are also common among physical health care treatment seekers. Estimates of alcohol abuse or dependence in primary health care settings range from 16-33% of all patients.8

Other Chronic Diseases

How does the prevalence of substance use disorders compare with other chronic diseases? The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) define chronic disease as prolonged, incurable diseases that do not spontaneously resolve.9 The CDC’s estimates of general population prevalence rates of asthma, diabetes, and hypertension are 5%, 2.9%, and 10.7% respectively.10 From this perspective, alcohol dependence is more prevalent than asthma, diabetes, or hypertension. Drug dependence has approximately the same prevalence as diabetes.

McLellan and colleagues11 investigated further the similarities of asthma, type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and drug dependence. They found that drug dependence was similar to the other chronic illnesses in terms of heritability, role of personal responsibility for disease management, and pathophysiology.

Download the Research Update
Read More
Substance Use in the Workplace

Substance Use in the Workplace

Information about workplace prevention and intervention programs Read More >

Read More
Teen Intervene prevention and education program

Early Alcohol and Drug Use Among Teens and Youth

Examining factors impacting early use of alcohol & other drugs Read More >

Read More
Young Woman in Hooded Sweatshirt Gazing Left

Prevalence of Adolescent Substance Misuse

Adolescent substance misuse trends shown by a recent nationwide study Read More >